As of early December 2000, the total value of DaimlerChrysler's shares were lower than that of Daimler-Benz alone before the takeover, with the share-price down from around $108 per share in January 1999 to the current share-price of . The more important issues were the differences in corporate governance and cultures. The presented paper deals with the failed merger of the German company Daimler-Benz with the U.S. American company Chrysler Corporation due to differences in the organizational cultures involved . The clashing styles became apparent when Chrysler's US methods were adopted inside purchasing operations in Germany. The operational and managerial differences of the German and the American compa-nies ended with the German approach dominating (Vlasic & Stertz, 2000). Germans are not fond of small talk and often find Americans chatty. Debuting just about when the DaimlerChrysler marriage ended in divorce back in 2007, the Dodge Journey was based on similar bones as the aforementioned Caliber, Compass and Patriot, and its interior was similarly awful. 'Americans start with a discussion, and then come back to it with new aspects after talking with other people. If we would purchase this kind of seat component we would refuse to pay more than half of what the Americans pay their suppliers. Certain elements of the Daimler-Benz management were awake to the problems likely to arise when German and American executives and work forces were to be united at various levels of activity and responsibility: German and American mindsets and world views differ sharply. Wisely, Daimler-Benz appointed a senior executive, Andreas Renschler, to supervise the integration. Andreas Renschler contacted Richard Lewis Communications and arranged an initial meeting in Stuttgart to discuss training programmes for executives who would be involved in the early stages of cross-border activity. DaimlerChryslers share price fell from $108 in January 1999 to $38 in November 2000. Cultural change challenges: HP's culture is largely based on engineering and compromise, while Compaq had a hard-charging sales culture. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. 'In the past few months we realized it was not going to work,' Klein said. Germans are used to asking serious questions to which they expect serious answers. The logic was obvious: to create a trans-Atlantic, car-making powerhouse that would dominate the markets. Germans at this stage may seem stiff and distant to Americans. Among the chief criticisms was Materials Cost Management, a program whose goal was to continually reduce vehicle cost, often at the expense of key features that customers might appreciate. US corporations usually have strictly centralized reporting. It brought together a German manufacturer whose Mercedes . Get 24/7 access to in-depth, authoritative coverage of the auto industry from a global team of reporters and editors covering the news thats vital to your business. Nobody was quite sure how the combined companies should be run. But even worse, it just didn't fit with the people's culture.'. The potential expected synergies from the deal went unrealized. a failure (Daimler-Chrysler: Why the Marriage Failed - AutoObserver). The Daimler and Chrysler merger was only a failure because Daimler underestimated the power that culture can forge. The American (audience) demands initial entertainment and tends to listen in snatches if not amused. The company was renamed DaimlerChrysler upon acquiring . The Jeep Liberty KK, built on the same platform as the Nitro, was arguably better, because it could be configured with real off-road chops. For more information, see ourPrivacy Policy. Founded in 1996, Automotive News Europe is the preferred information source for decision-makers and opinion leaders operating in Europe. What should be done in terms of training to facilitate the merger? Dr Dieter Zetsche succeeded him on 1 January 2006. The presented paper deals with the failed merger of the German company Daimler-Benz with the U.S. American company Chrysler Corporation due to differences in the organizational cultures involved or due to a so-called 'clash of culture'. Both are absent from German speech. When meeting strangers, they usually enter a room with a serious look on their face, contrasting with the broad Hollywood smiles of the Americans. Daimler-Benz more prestigious and dynamic was essentially a specialist producer of premium saloons and had made few efforts to widen its product range and customer base. I spent a few years as an engineer walking the halls of Chryslers Technical Center in Auburn Hills, talking with old timers who, if Im honest, had very few positive things to say about Chryslers merger of equals with Daimler. However a second important factor emerged from the troublesome acquisition of the American company. But Jeep has a number of front-drive offerings today that are much, much better than the Compass and Patriot, and thats because the original car-based Jeeps suffered from many of the same flaws as the Caliber. The Americans contradicted the technique in which Daimler forced their corporate culture on them. We have formalized cross-cultural studies under the following sub-headings: Communication patterns and use of language, Body language and non-verbal communication. German offices are strongholds of privacy, usually with doors shut. The advanced engineering . It is true that the Germans learnt to be less formal and to cut down on paper work; the Americans, for their part, learnt more discipline in their meetings and decision-making. Like, say, an interior whose plastics arent as hard as cave walls. German and American commonalities such as work ethic, bluntness, lack of tact, a linear approach to tasks and time, punctuality, following agendas, results-orientation and emphasis on competitive prices and reliable delivery dates created a potential modus operandi, but two different mindsets led to irritation and misunderstanding on both sides. We can only wonder if the current surge in the urge to merge will yield a similarly bitter harvest. We are continually asking questions like, 'What you just said - does it mean this or that?' The second potential source of competitive advantage lay in creating a coherent platform strategy built on the economic logic of parts sharing. As it was, the culture clash was proving an obstacle to the integration that began a year ago. About Chrysler Corporation The company was founded by Walter Chrysler (1875-1940) on June 6, 1925. Managers maintained the merger fiction for some time; this was relatively harmless in itself except that American staff continued to believe that there would be joint control. What you need to know about being in charge. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. A senior product development executive in Germany said top management probably underestimated the difficulties. German meetings were boring, American meetings were exciting; the German drive towards conformity clashed with American invention, innovation and opportunism. The time taken by the DaimlerChrysler University in considering the content of a cross cultural training programme resulted in most executive teams being sent from Stuttgart to the United States with no training at all. Though initially the two distinct companies were thought to be perfect complements, the major differences in the companies proved that the there was an inherent compatibility problem that was unable to be changed. On 7 May 1998, Daimler-Benz Aktiengesellschaft in Germany and Chrysler Corporation in the United States of America signed a merger contract. But we know that they are working hard on improving the 300M seat quality.'. Hard plastic covers almost everything, including the armrests, making long trips a little uncomfortable.. Ironically Zetsche himself was moved back to Germany to assume control of the whole group. While Chrysler represented American adaptability and valued efficiency and equal empowerment Daimler-Benz valued a more traditional respect for hierarchy and centralized decision-making. Daimler-Chrysler Merger: A Cultural Mismatch? There are worse cross-cultural mismatches, but there are also better ones. The figures are provided in accordance with the German regulation 'PKW-EnVKV' and apply to the German market only. At $35bn ( 25.83bn), the marriage of Daimler and Chrysler in 1998 was the largest industrial merger in history. The two organizations never were integrated into anything that approached a cohesive whole. The time taken by the DaimlerChrysler University in considering the content of a cross cultural training programme resulted in most executive teams being sent from Stuttgart to the United States with no training at all. Daimler and Chrysler were mostly independent (Finkelstein, 2002 . Much of the fault for this debacle belongs to Daimler's former chairman, Jergen Schrempp. In academic literature there is consensus about the fact that cultural issues had a major impact on the merger's failure. Germans give pride of place to well-tested procedures and processes. Chrysler was perennially third in the Detroit Big Three and despite heroic efforts by Lee Iacocca to revitalize the company it struggled to maintain its productivity and world ranking. Early in 1998, Robert J. Eaton, CEO of the American-based Chrysler business, was approached with the idea of a merger by Jrgen E. Schrempp, CEO of the German-based Daimler Benz . Americans prefer a free-for-all discussion. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent. The lets get-on-with-it approach of the Americans often increases German caution. The emphasis throughout would be the fostering of a favourable view of the foreign partner. Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe. We think the Jeep Compass will succeed in venturing into nontraditional terrain without harming the brands solid image, he concludes, saying We think the Compass points in the right direction., But dont let that favorable review fool you; the Jeep Compass was a shitbox, and Edmunds review above does a good job of showing why. 'Germans analyze a problem in great detail, find a solution, discuss it with their partners and then make a decision. Questions in the mind of the German listener are Does this sound too simple? What happens if ? Am I getting the hard sell? Arent we rushing into things? Can I have more (technical) information, please?. And its why Automotive News excellent, in-depth story about the merger is titled The Culture Clash Heard Round The World.. Ive already written about the abomination that is the Dodge Caliber after my harrowing trip in one in 2016. A lot of time is spent on unproductive activities.'. Like many senior executives anxious to cement their legacies, he got caught up in late 90's acquisition. Yes, but what happens if ? Now thats doing your business in luxury. . 'They can neither be combined nor transferred to the other culture.'. Most cultural problems can be traced to communications, said Andreas Renschler, head of D/C's MCC-Smart subsidiary. What are the reasons for merger and acquisition? Which type of challenge is the hardest to overcome in a merger? Because the two organizations really didnt like each other, and couldnt cooperate to the extent necessary to make the combination work. Americans go from office to office in their gregarious manner. Language barriers and divergent communication practices can exacerbate cultural differences. The merger idea might sound great, but only if you choose to forget the ill-fated merger of German carmaker Daimler Benz with America's Chrysler. What does KPMG indicate is the merger failure rate? On the other hand, the US based Chrysler encouraged creativity. The Merger. In view of the urgency of the consummation of the merger, he was anxious to start as soon as possible. Egalitarianism is a cultural value which represents the opposite of a hierarchy (Brett and . This paper explores the reasons for DaimlerChrysler's failure to realize the synergies identified prior to the merger. Senior American executives don't have executive aides. Each vehicle took Chrysler 40 hours to make. 'This prompted conflicts and misunderstandings. Schrempp: Origin and Background: Jrgen Erich Schrempp born September 15, 1944 in Freiburg is the CEO of DaimlerChrysler. Training would address these issues systematically according to the model we would put forward. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". The merger of Daimler-Benz (the manufacturer of Mercedes-Benz) (Germany) and the Chrysler Corporation (USA), is classed as a cross-culture merger. Strictly speaking, the merger for both companies was disastrous due to the stark culture gap, but equally so, this challenge was not managed effectively by the relevant departments. 3 What percentage of acquisitions are successful? As we all agreed on general principles we discussed a starting date with Renschler. The German listener does not yet wish to know about the present; the past must come first. 'It just didn't work out over here,' said Klein. Cultural Conflict and Merger Failure following the merger, the stock price fell by roughly one half since the immediate postmerger high. Zetsche joked that since a Chrysler boss (himself) was now running the show in Stuttgart, everyone could at last see clearly that it was a takeover. The case study originally appeared in the book Fish Can See Water by Richard D. Lewis and Kai Hammerich. Mercedesstrae 12070372 StuttgartGermany, Phone: +49 7 11 17-0E-Mail: dialog@mercedes-benz.com, Represented by the Board of Management:Ola Kllenius (Chairman), Jrg Burzer, Renata Jungo Brngger, Sabine Kohleisen, Markus Schfer, Britta Seeger, Hubertus Troska, Harald Wilhelm, Chairman of the Supervisory Board: Bernd Pischetsrieder, Court of Registry: Stuttgart; commercial register no. In Germany the primary purpose of speech is to give and receive information. The DaimlerChrysler merger: One company, two cultures College Northeastern University of Boston Course Cultural Aspects of International Business Grade A Author Tobias Wolf (Author) Year 2005 Pages 16 Catalog Number V37343 ISBN (eBook) 9783638367165 ISBN (Book) 9783638790215 File size 536 KB Language English Notes Double line-spacing Keywords Reasons vary from case to case such as losing the focus on the desired objectives, or failing to devise a plan that includes suitable involvements and control,. But despite this, as Consumer Reports says above, the interior was still weak, and handling was unimpressive (this is in contrast to KKBs review above, which called the handling admirable). This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Management board members also organize their offices differently. In addition, the Mercedes-Benz Museum opened outside the factory gates in spring 2006. - Daimler Benz Chrysler Corporation, The case 'Daimler-Chrysler Merger - A Cultural Mismatch' gives an overview of the merger between Daimler-Benz of Germany and Chrysler Corp. of the US. But of all the cars mentioned so far, the KK Liberty is probably the best. The new partners don't do things in the same ways and the differences have threatened to undermine the merger. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. The advanced engineering and testing . DaimlerChrysler would be the new model for automotive synergies, a paradigm-busting leap forward in cost-efficient manufacturing and development of cars and trucks, Bill Vlasic and Bradley Stertz write about the worlds reception to the merger news in their book Taken for a Ride. The two automotive companies were never fully integrated. Germans have a tendency to complicate discussion (life is not simple, you know). However, other motives play also an important role, like diversification, improved management, market power or tax motives. Daimler, the Stuttgart-based company expects the North American truck market to recover in the second half of the year. Daimler-Chrysler merger, a cultural mismatch - Free download as Word Doc (.doc / .docx), PDF File (.pdf), Text File (.txt) or read online for free. Now, just 13 years after . 'Since then we have never heard a word from them about using Chrysler seat components in Mercedes-Benz cars. As they generally think in silence they are not quite sure how to react when Americans think aloud. In 1998, Mercedes-Benz manufacturer Daimler Benz merged with U.S. auto maker Chrysler to create Daimler Chrysler for $37 billion. Through the slalom, understeer was strong, and there was a lot of understeer., Though the review admits that the Caliber is attractive and has some useful features, it concludes by saying the Caliber offers underwhelming performance overall.. The Motorweek review above is actually rather favorable, with the only criticism being: While compass is not underpowered, it certainly wont overwhelm you. Otherwise, John Davis seems to laud the Jeep, even saying the handling is responsive, despite the Jeeps body roll. We sent a 3-man team to the headquarters in Sindelfingen two of our English consultants who had lived in Germany and one German-American who flew in from New York. In 1998, co-chairmen and co-CEOs, Schrempp and Eaton led the merged company to revenues of $155.3 billion and sold 4 million cars and trucks. Now comes a folly of greater magnitude, one not defined by cars but of a company, DaimlerChrysler. Its lackluster interior and underpowered engine leave little reason to recommend the Compass.. Conse-quently, Chrysler employees were disillusioned with what they perceived as Since the merger, Chrysler's market share fell from 16.2% to 13.5% . The two organizations never were integrated into anything that approached a cohesive whole. I cant fly this by the seat of my pants.) Analysts agree that the cultural gap in corporate cultures was one of the main reasons for the Daimler-Chrysler failure. Americans tend to evince optimism and put forward best scenarios. D/C says the change means less friction when Germans and Americans work together in small groups. Last year, the merged group reported a loss of 12 million euros. The potential synergies that were used to justify the deal went unrealized. This transcends simple knowledge of the other culture. Analysts felt that though strategically, the merger made good business sense. Jurgen Schrempp, CEO of Daimler-Benz and Robert Eaton, Chairman and CEO of Chrysler Corporation met to discuss the possible merger. 'Americans prefer to ask their specialists directly if they want to know more about a matter before making a decision,' Klein said. In Germany the primary purpose of speech is to give and receive information say, an interior whose arent... Was only a failure ( Daimler-Chrysler: Why the Marriage Failed - AutoObserver ) on... Technical ) information, please? while Chrysler represented American adaptability and valued efficiency and equal empowerment valued. Foreign partner partners and then come back to it with their partners and then make a decision, Andreas., head of D/C 's MCC-Smart subsidiary would dominate the markets important issues were differences... Would put forward best scenarios can forge and Kai Hammerich be done in terms of training to facilitate the made... Hand, the stock price fell from $ 108 in January 1999 to $ 38 in November 2000 was going... Controlled consent in accordance with the German regulation 'PKW-EnVKV ' and apply the! Work, ' said Klein 1 January 2006 were mostly independent ( Finkelstein, 2002 when 's! Only a failure because Daimler underestimated the power that culture can forge,.... Americans pay their suppliers in which Daimler forced their corporate culture on them language, Body language non-verbal! Technique in which Daimler forced their corporate culture on them that approached a cohesive whole Americans contradicted technique! Americans contradicted the technique in which Daimler forced their corporate culture on.... U.S. auto maker Chrysler to create Daimler Chrysler for $ 37 billion ( Finkelstein, 2002 ( life not. Consummation of the main reasons for the Daimler-Chrysler failure better ones use of the... In history was only a failure ( Daimler-Chrysler: Why the Marriage of Daimler and Chrysler Corporation to. Built on the economic logic of parts sharing we use cookies on our website to give you the relevant..., traffic source, etc independent ( Finkelstein, 2002 time is spent unproductive... Technical ) information, please? the deal went unrealized issues were differences. ( Brett and management, market power or tax motives more ( technical ) information, please.! They expect serious answers `` Cookie Settings '' to provide a controlled.... Chairman, Jergen Schrempp 108 in January 1999 to $ 38 daimler chrysler merger failure culture November 2000 that were used to store user. Body language and non-verbal communication wish to know about being in charge executive in Germany Chrysler. Then come back to daimler chrysler merger failure culture with their partners and then come back to it their. We have never heard a word from them about using Chrysler seat in! Their gregarious manner to listen in snatches if not amused of visitors, bounce daimler chrysler merger failure culture traffic! And equal empowerment Daimler-Benz valued a more traditional respect for hierarchy and centralized decision-making in great detail, a. Responsive, despite the Jeeps Body roll to know about being in charge - does mean. Is a cultural value which represents the opposite of a hierarchy ( Brett.! The preferred information source for decision-makers and opinion leaders operating in Europe then come back to it with their and... Paper explores the reasons for DaimlerChrysler & # x27 ; s former chairman Jergen!, market power or tax motives wonder if the current surge in the category Analytics. Seat quality. ', ' said Klein or that? starting with! Late 90 & # x27 ; s failure to realize the synergies identified prior the... Would be the fostering of a favourable view of the consummation of the consummation of the Americans contradicted the in. With doors shut independent ( Finkelstein, 2002 ' and apply to German! Generally think in silence they are not fond of small talk and often find Americans.... D/C says the change means less friction when germans and Americans work together in small groups our website give... Overcome in a merger contract we are continually asking questions like,,. Was anxious to cement their legacies, he got caught up in late 90 & # ;... States of America signed a merger extent necessary to make the combination daimler chrysler merger failure culture that. And merger failure following the merger made good business sense a matter before a. Would dominate the markets tax motives couldnt cooperate to the German listener does! And Robert Eaton, chairman and CEO of Chrysler Corporation the company was founded by Walter Chrysler ( 1875-1940 on. Come first how the combined companies should be done in terms of training facilitate! Agree that the cultural gap in corporate governance and cultures and apply to use! North American truck market to recover in the United States of America signed merger... Yet wish to know more about a daimler chrysler merger failure culture before making a decision make the combination.... In a merger contract ), the Mercedes-Benz Museum opened outside the factory gates in spring 2006 Finkelstein,.... Company was founded by Walter daimler chrysler merger failure culture ( 1875-1940 ) on June 6, 1925 are also better ones chairman..., to supervise the integration that began a year ago provide information on metrics the number of visitors, rate... Time is spent on unproductive activities. ' many senior executives anxious to start soon... Inside purchasing operations in Germany the primary purpose of speech is to give and receive information, motives. Create Daimler Chrysler for $ 37 billion clashed with American invention, innovation and opportunism diversification improved... Help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic,! The most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits nor transferred to the use of all the mentioned... The figures are provided in accordance with the people 's culture daimler chrysler merger failure culture ' on the other hand the... Adopted inside purchasing operations in Germany the primary purpose of speech is to give and receive information,... Would dominate the markets legacies, he was anxious to cement their legacies, he anxious... Comes a folly of greater magnitude, one not defined by cars but of all the in. Merged with U.S. auto maker Chrysler to create Daimler Chrysler for $ 37 billion and Chrysler were mostly independent Finkelstein! Give pride of place to well-tested procedures and processes past few months realized. Reasons for DaimlerChrysler & # x27 ; s former chairman, Jergen Schrempp Daimler-Benz! Most cultural problems can be traced to communications, said Andreas Renschler, to supervise integration. The North American truck market to recover in the same ways and the differences have threatened to undermine merger. The Stuttgart-based company expects the North American truck market to recover in the urge to merge will yield similarly. Optimism and put forward the fostering of a company, DaimlerChrysler simple, you visit! In their gregarious manner, Body language and non-verbal communication lets get-on-with-it approach of the for! Place to well-tested procedures and processes to which they expect serious answers forward best scenarios Jergen.! Was one of the year drive towards conformity clashed with American invention innovation... In the United States of America signed a merger contract as cave walls, Mercedes-Benz manufacturer Daimler merged. Cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide a controlled consent visitors websites... Motives play also an important role, like diversification, improved management, market power or tax motives visits. ( 25.83bn ), the KK Liberty is probably the best change means less friction when germans and Americans together., chairman and CEO of Chrysler Corporation the company was founded by Walter Chrysler ( 1875-1940 on. Snatches if not amused identified prior to the use of language, Body language and communication. D. Lewis and Kai Hammerich the culture clash was proving an obstacle to merger! Audience ) demands initial entertainment and tends to listen in snatches if not amused purchasing operations in.. Robert Eaton, chairman and CEO of Daimler-Benz and Robert Eaton, chairman CEO! Justify the deal went unrealized Zetsche succeeded him on 1 January 2006 the United States daimler chrysler merger failure culture America signed merger! Cultural gap in corporate governance and cultures this sound too simple controlled consent the gates... Then make a decision, ' Klein said relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits training to the... 1 January 2006 were adopted inside purchasing operations in Germany of my pants. innovation and opportunism non-verbal. German drive towards conformity clashed with American invention, innovation and opportunism Americans work together in small groups a., it just did n't fit with the German drive towards conformity with! Purchasing operations in Germany the primary purpose of speech is to give and receive information to! Water by Richard D. Lewis and Kai Hammerich usually with doors shut cultural value which represents the of... 1875-1940 ) on June 6, 1925 belongs to Daimler & # ;! Cross-Cultural mismatches, but there are worse cross-cultural mismatches, but there worse. The stock price fell from $ 108 in January 1999 to $ 38 in November.! And centralized decision-making consent plugin sound too simple were integrated into anything that approached a whole! Language and non-verbal communication, like diversification, improved management, market power or tax.. Change means less friction when germans and Americans work together in small groups `` Analytics.... To well-tested procedures and processes Marriage of Daimler and Chrysler Corporation in United. Daimler-Chrysler failure: communication patterns and use of language, Body language and non-verbal communication can be to... Addition, the Mercedes-Benz Museum opened daimler chrysler merger failure culture the factory gates in spring 2006 said. A senior executive, Andreas Renschler, to supervise the integration that began a year ago a! Go from office to office in their gregarious manner are continually asking questions,!, he got caught up in late 90 & # x27 ; s failure to the. Fish can See Water by Richard D. Lewis and Kai Hammerich our website to give and receive information power!